

In Broken Lance, Kansas, John Bonniwell (Richard Dix) becomes a local hero by running Jesse James' gang out of town. With a strong recommendation from bank owner and prominent citizen Steve Barat (Albert Dekker), Bonniwell is appointed town marshal. He accepts the job, in part to impress lovely local hotel owner Eleanor Sager (Jane Wyatt), and soon learns that not only is Barat corrupt, his intentions are to use John's esteemed reputation to mask his evil-doings and facilitate his rise to power. Trapped between a rock and a hard place, Bonniwell must come up with a plan to relieve Barat of his power, all the while revealing him as the villain he is to the people of Broken Lance.